Friday 5

Not another tote-bag

23 October, 2026

There’s always a small thrill in receiving a free tote bag or water bottle; free items feel exciting, and doubly so when they’re sustainable too. But as these well-intentioned symbols of eco-friendly behaviour multiply, and you find yourself stuffing a tenth unused water bottle into an abandoned cupboard at home, we risk ending up back where we started: consuming more stuff in the name of consuming less.

Despite this, new research has identified “sustainable additive bias”, a tendency we have to view adding eco-friendly products as a stronger signal of sustainability than reducing consumption altogether, even when the latter has a greater environmental benefit. Across nine studies spanning hotels, conferences, festivals and trade shows, people consistently rewarded visible additions, such as organic toiletries replacing non-organic ones, but gave much less credit to organisations that simply removed unnecessary items. In one experiment, hotel rooms stocked with a range of eco-friendly amenities were rated as more sustainable than rooms with fewer amenities, despite the smaller environmental footprint of the latter. It seems that when a change is visible, we’re more likely to interpret it as evidence that something positive has happened.

The study also found that this bias can be reduced when organisations explain why products have been removed. When people understand that fewer amenities, fewer promotional items, or less packaging are deliberate efforts to reduce waste and conserve resources, they’re much more likely to view those changes positively. The lesson is simple: if you want people recognise your sustainability efforts, explain what you’ve changed and why. And if you’d like support applying behavioural science insights like these to your own work, we’d love to help.

By Rosie Serlin